The Legend of 1900
“An epic story of a man who could do anything... except be ordinary”
The Legend of 1900 (1998) is a drama, music film directed by Giuseppe Tornatore.
On Plot-hole, players averaged 0.5/5, with 18% solving the puzzle and 82% failing it, making it the #2 brutalest puzzle of 137 in the archive. Musician Max Tooney goes to sell his prized Conn trumpet to a music shop, where he plays the instrument one last time. The shopkeeper recognises the song as one on a record matrix he found and asks who the piece is by. Tooney tells the story of an infant found abandoned in the first class dining room of the four-stacker ocean-liner SS Virginian on 1 January 1900. Danny Boodman, a coal-man from the boiler room, names the boy Danny Boodman T. D. Lemon 1900, after himself, the fruit crate the boy was found in, and the year, and raises him as his own.
Plot-hole Difficulty: Brutal
The Plot-hole Puzzle
Puzzle #99 · June 26, 2026 · answer revealed below
The Setup (Clue 5)
A lavish ship sailing to America in the early 1900s.
The Character (Clue 4)
A baby is found abandoned on the ship and raised aboard.
The Conflict (Clue 3)
He never leaves the ship his entire life.
The Twist (Clue 2)
He becomes the greatest piano player the world has never truly seen.
The Spoiler (Clue 1)
Tim Roth plays a pianist who was born on a ship and refuses to set foot on land.
The answer
The Legend of 1900
Cast
Tim Roth as Danny Boodmann T.D. Lemon Nineteen Hundred '1900'Pruitt Taylor Vince as Max TooneyMélanie Thierry as The GirlBill Nunn as Danny BoodmannGabriele Lavia as FarmerClarence Williams III as Jelly Roll MortonPeter Vaughan as 'Pops', the ShopkeeperNiall O'Brien as Harbor Master
Frequently Asked Questions
- Is The Legend of 1900 hard to guess on Plot-hole?
- The Legend of 1900 had an average score of 0.5/5. 18% of players solved it, while 82% failed — a brutal puzzle.
- Who directed The Legend of 1900?
- The Legend of 1900 was directed by Giuseppe Tornatore.
- Who stars in The Legend of 1900?
- The Legend of 1900 stars Tim Roth, Pruitt Taylor Vince, Mélanie Thierry, Bill Nunn, Gabriele Lavia, Clarence Williams III, Peter Vaughan, Niall O'Brien.
- What genre is The Legend of 1900?
- The Legend of 1900 is listed under Drama, Music.
- Where does The Legend of 1900 rank in Plot-hole difficulty?
- The Legend of 1900 ranks #2 of 137 Plot-hole movies by average score (1 = hardest).
Advertisement